I used a variation on your method... I used a metal paper clamp (on the left) to hold the proper sized piece of plastic to the key, then I heated the blade of an exacto-knife with a small pen torch and it cut through it like an exacto-knife through butter... hehe.
it works great, and as you both mentioned it requires the use of my tension tool to function correctly. The time to produce this (after I got the brilliant idea to heat the knife) was about a minute, isn't that awesome?
Thank you so much for showing the world how to do this!
