After an inital pick buying debacle I've decided that, for now, my best course of action is to make my own picks. It seems to be cheaper that way. Here's what I'm using.
dremel tool
wide aluminum oxide bit for grinding
bullet shaped felt bit for polishing
polishing compound
plumbing snake from home depot
big vice grips
600 grit wet/dry sandpaper
sharpie marker
round sandpaper discs for the dremel
I start out cutting 5" sections of plumbing snake with the vice grips. Actually, I score it with the vise grips then break it off. you have to really crank on them to get the cutter to score it deeply enough to keep it from bending instead of breaking. If it bends, then you've either got a bent end or bent butt. either way, not really welcome.
After obtaining a 5" pick blank, I round off one end to a semicircle and deburr it with the grinder. This allows me to hold it in my hand more comfortably than if it had a sharp newly cut corner. I then take a sharpie and place a mark across the blank abotu 1.25-1.5 inches from the end opposite the rounding i just did. this tells me where the shoulder of the pick is going to be.
i take the aluminum oxide bit and grind away until the pick is the shape i want. for more detailed picks (king/queen/rakes. etc.) I use a second aluminum oxide bit. the rough shaping tends to wear the bit down fairly quickly, so if I need sharp angles, I need a new bit that hasn't had it's corners rounded.
Once the rough shaping has been completedI take a fine grained sandpaper disc and deburr all of the cut edges. once completed, i use the 600 grit sandpaper to polish all surfaces as much as possible. I've found that by sanding everything lengthwise, i can get a better polish and a better feel initially in the lock. the cuts in the pick usualy have to be sanded perpendicular to the pick because there isn't enough room to get much of a stroke. For the tighter radius cuts, i wrap a strip of sandpaper aroud a pick blank until the sandpaper radius matches the size of the area I'm sanding.
Once the sanding has been completed, I use the bullet shaped polishing bit and the dremel polishing compound (overpriced. at $2.50 jewellers rouge is the same stuff and runs 3x as much for about 10x as much product) I polish all surfaces being sure to spend lots of time on all areas that will touch the pins. This leaves me with a nearly mirror finish that glides very smoothly across the pins and through the keyway.
I've noticed that with the dremel, I have trouble keeping the pick aligned with such a small bit. this leads to the pick periodically sliding off the bit and leaving unpolishable grind marks in the sides of the pick and nicks in the corners. They don't seem to affect the use of the pick adversely that I can tell, but it would be nice if I could get a single perfect pick completed without those flaws.
I'm left with a pick that slides in and out of the lock very easily, has great responsiveness, and transmits feedback to my hand without the feel being dulled by friction. It takes about 15 minutes to complete each pick. Maybe a bit longer to complete a king/queen due to the precision needed. I think I could significantly reduce that time if I had an adequate bench grinder with a polishing mandrel and disk, though the lack of precision in polishing might cause more problems than the speed would solve. A second person to polish and sand while I grind would help a grat deal as well since the process of changing bits and tasks lead to too much downtime and taks switching overhead.
My next project will probably be to get some brass sheeting to make profile templates for my more favorite picks. This would allow a quick comparison between the pick and the ideal design. being made from brass, It would allow me to be more precise with the design and also allow hundreds of uses before needing replacement. I don't plan on going into businesswith this, but I do know a number of people who don't get into lockpicking simply because of the difficulty in selecting and ordering picks and the cost of a good set.