Let me begin by saying I'm a beginner. I apologize in advance if what I say seems silly or stupid.

I have a relatively new Master combination-lock. I believe it is less than a year old. Today, I was trying to bypass it with a makeshift shim that I made out of an aluminum can using this method.
This is the shim, after a frustrating battle with the lock:

This is the lock. Note the entryway for the hasp and the minuscule space between the two:

And this is my attempt at using the shim to bypass the lock:

(Sorry about picture quality and crappy editing

The shim is 2.5 inches X 1 inch and it is made of a normal aluminum can. The cuts were made along a letter "M" pattern along quarter lines (like in the video). This may help clarify it:

The gray parts are cut away. The top segment is folded down. Then the "wings" are folded around the top, leaving the middle spike protruding.
Now with the details out of the way, I'll explain the problem I'm having. I fold the shim around the hasp to make it the right shape, and then I stick the sharp part into the space between the hasp and the hull as far as it will go (which, mind you, is NOT very far at all). Then I twist the shim, holding onto the wings, clockwise, to try and bypass the lock. While I'm doing this twisting motion, the sharp part of the shim slips out of the lock. This happens every time. If I try to force it, the shim crumples and I have to make a new one.
So here's my question. Is this lock "shim-proof", did I make the shim incorrectly, or am I doing something wrong with my technique?
Thanks for reading my wall of text!

-Greg