I have a Masterlock No. 5 that to this day I can't SPP, but I can rake it open in seconds with my bogota and a serrated tension wrench.
Sounds like they are not binding in the correct order, so I'd just keep at it. I've had a few where the last pin is sassy, and sometimes heavier tension is what is needed even though it is counter intuitive.
Perhaps someone else here will have some better insight

-FM