If you've gotten it to false set, don't let off tension. Go in and find the pin that pushes back against you on the tension wrench. Then, and ONLY then (while it's pushing back) should you let up on the tension and only as much as it is pushing back. It may seem counter-intuitive but, you actually have to let the plug rotate back (or be pushed back) as you're setting that pin.
You're probably up against one or more spool pins. If you lose some other pin sets while setting this one, don't worry about it. I've got a 5-pin lock with 5 spools and it's like 15 steps to pick it and one pin gets picked 4 different times it seems. You just have to do what the lock tells you. Your lock is telling "You're almost there."
I personally love spool pins for this very reason. Except for my Brinks shrouded. That S-0-B. I still like it but, it is a bear to get open in less than a minute. Everything else I own I can pop in less than 30secs, including my other Brinks "Max" security locks. That shrouded S-0-B likes to be a pain in my butt.
If you want to see an example of what I'm talking about with letting the spool pin push back against your tension wrench, take a look at my #911 video.
http://www.youtube.com/user/JohnOPSEC Pay careful attention to when I'm picking the 4th and 5th spool pins. You can really see then push back against me and rotate the plug the opposite way you would think.