I have a question for you all. My friend brought me a masterlock #3 of his for me to try my hand at opening. I have opened up about 5 or so different masterlock #3s that my different friends have (really common lock around here I guess). I can usually open them within a couple minutes, sometimes they pop open right away.
I haven't been able to open it yet

The cylinder is really loose inside the lock. It wiggles in and out and to the side. I am getting zero feedback from my tension wrench at all. It's like I can't even tension it properly due to the loose nature of the cylinder. What causes a lock to get a loose cylinder like that? And is there a better way to pick it? I have tried all my raking techniques and SPP it as well.
I doesn't give any feeling like any other lock I've picked so far. How weird that an old beat up lock that has a loose cylinder is SO much harder to pick than a brand new shiny one...
Any advice, comments, or criticism are welcome. Thank you
