Hi
My Dad has an old Cary safe that came with the house. The house was built in 1890 so we speculate the safe was brought in around then. It certainly won't fit through any of the doors. We have a combination (not giving the real numbers). My Dad has seen it opened with that combination but it was when he bought the place 20 years ago. There hasn't been any maintenance.
The dial has numbers 20 through 100 with a blank space between 100 and 20. There is a spinning dial in the middle of the door and a handle with a straight bar horizontal to the floor just to the left of the dial.
The middle of the dial says " Sargent & Greenleaf, Rochester NY" with patent dates in the middle from Sept. 18 1860 -through July 14 1871.
The combination goes
Left 4 to 20
Right 3 to 43
Left 2 to 85
Right to 88 and open
I've seen a few other answers for Cary safes but one thing never addressed is how to you reset the dial? Like on a modern locker lock you twirl it left/clock wise five times and then start. I just want to open the d*** thing, it's driving me nuts!