Lock Picking 101 Forum
A community dedicated to the fun and ethical hobby of lock picking.
       

Lock Picking 101 Home
Login
Profile
Members
Forum Rules
Frequent Forum Questions
SEARCH
View New Posts
View Active Topics


Live Chat on Discord
LP101 Forum Chat
Keypicking Forum Chat
Reddit r/lockpicking Chat



Learn How to Pick Locks
FAQs & General Questions
Got Beginner Questions?
Pick-Fu [Intermediate Level]


Ask a Locksmith
This Old Lock
This Old Safe
What Lock Should I Buy?



Hardware
Locks
Lock Patents
Lock Picks
Lock Bumping
Lock Impressioning
Lock Pick Guns, Snappers
European Locks & Picks
The Machine Shop
The Open Source Lock
Handcuffs


Member Spotlight
Member Introductions
Member Lock Collections
Member Social Media


Off Topic
General Chatter
Other Puzzles


Locksmith Business Info
Training & Licensing
Running a Business
Keyways & Key Blanks
Key Machines
Master Keyed Systems
Closers and Crash Bars
Life Safety Compliance
Electronic Locks & Access
Locksmith Supplies
Locksmith Lounge


Buy Sell Trade
Buy - Sell - Trade
It came from Ebay!


Advanced Topics
Membership Information
Special Access Required:
High Security Locks
Vending Locks
Advanced Lock Pick Tools
Bypass Techniques
Safes & Safe Locks
Automotive Entry & Tools
Advanced Buy/Sell/Trade


Locksport Groups
Locksport Local
Chapter President's Office
Locksport Board Room
 

Otto smart lock

Thinking of upgrading your door security? Getting a better deadbolt or padlock? Getting a new frame or better hinges? Not sure what brand or model to go with for your particular application? Need a recommendation? Feel free to ask for advice here!

Otto smart lock

Postby bitbuster » 1 Jan 2018 10:16

"I dream of a world where, chickens can cross the road without having their motives questioned". Ralph Waldo Emerson
bitbuster
 
Posts: 330
Joined: 6 Aug 2009 14:46
Location: NW Wis

Re: Otto smart lock

Postby Jacob Morgan » 1 Jan 2018 11:53

The cost was $700, plus $150 for the install. The designers thought that what held back consumers from such locks was neither security nor cost, but was how cool it looked. So they hired a bunch of Apple employees to make it look cool. Here is a link with a more in-depth description: https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/24/otto-is-betting-people-will-pay-700-for-a-premium-smart-lock/

So many screwed up things about the story:

1. Zero-day hacks. These things tend to be blown wide open by the hacker community months after coming out, and when the vulnerability is found, they are all susceptible until the factory figures out a countermeasure and gets it out into the market. On the other hand, there simply is no zero-day hack against quality mechanical locks. Sure a person can practice and study and learn how to pick mechanical locks, and then spend time being exposed while they try to pick one, one that might put up a fight for several minutes or longer. But a smart lock, once hacked, allows anyone with the hacked key to open any such lock instantly, even remotely. Add to that the fun of ransom-ware and who knows what else that comes along.

2. The company bragged about how many ex-Apple, Nokia, and Microsoft employees the company had. It made no mention of how many locksmith or hardware industry employees the company had--it appears not to have crossed their minds.

3. This unit had a sort of reserve battery if the main battery died. The reserve battery could only be replaced by the factory. If the reserve battery gave out, there was no way to open the lock short of blunt force trauma (finally, a use for scammers!) Never an issue with quality mechanical locks.

4. If one merely wanted a good looking lock, for the price of one of these, one could buy a nice Baldwin mortise lock set and have it professionally installed. And it would probably still be working when the grandkids inherited the house. The target demographic might have been young hipsters exercising their type of conspicuous consumption--but most of them rent a hip apartment in a hip part of town, and their landlords are not hip to them changing locks, even if they do glow in the dark.

5. The rage these days in silicon valley is to have one good idea, start up a company of youngsters who work 18 hours a day for stock options and free orange juice, then sell the company to one of the few big technology companies for millions of dollars. And then let them figure out how to manufacturer and distribute it, and what to do if it has profound security flaws. So they really wanted Assa-Abloy to buy them out. Assa-Abloy was smart enough to pass on that so-called smart lock. I do not think it is in keeping with true innovation to brainstorm a cool toy in an all-nighter, have some ex-Apple employees make the outside of it look cool, then hype it up and try to sell it for millions. The best innovators were people who were at least willing to build what they designed--Yale designed locks and built them, Best designed SFIC and built them, one guy started LAB and not only designed what they sold but became the expert on the types of Swiss Screw machines used (i.e., they have a side business rebuilding them for other companies), Mr. Framon made the Framon machine, etc. On the other hand, this company is folding simply because no one bought them out--that is one goofy business plan.
Jacob Morgan
Supporter
Supporter
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30 Dec 2015 21:31
Location: KY (north west)

Re: Otto smart lock

Postby demux » 1 Jan 2018 19:57

Jacob Morgan wrote:Mr. Framon made the Framon machine, etc. On the other hand, this company is folding simply because no one bought them out--that is one goofy business plan.


Frank Agius, actually.

http://www.framon.com/index.php/about-us/

But point well taken. There's certainly a lot of pride in taking something all the way through from a raw idea to a finished product. And pride in one's work does usually translate into quality output. Probably a reason all the companies you named are still around after decades in business...
demux
 
Posts: 516
Joined: 27 Apr 2017 11:14
Location: Indiana, USA

Re: Otto smart lock

Postby Jacob Morgan » 2 Jan 2018 14:45

demux wrote:
Jacob Morgan wrote:Mr. Framon made the Framon machine, etc. On the other hand, this company is folding simply because no one bought them out--that is one goofy business plan.


Frank Agius, actually.

http://www.framon.com/index.php/about-us/
...


My mistake. I recalled seeing a picture of him at a trade show where he was manning the Framon booth and for some reason I thought that was his name.
Jacob Morgan
Supporter
Supporter
 
Posts: 571
Joined: 30 Dec 2015 21:31
Location: KY (north west)


Return to What Lock Should I Buy?

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests