Man, that thing is giving me no end of trouble. It gives me zero feedback, but I imagine that's an issue with my tensioning technique. My question relates to the bitting of this particular lock: Both the package and the internet tell me it's a four pin lock, but when I count the pins I'm most certainly counting five. The key also looks to be bitted for a five-pin lock. So, how many pins are in the darn thing, and what's convincing me there are five?

The lock in question, with a AA battery for scale because I couldn't find my ruler.

Close-up of the key. Maybe I'm nuts, but I swear that thing has five cuts in it.
Any and all advice/suggestions are appreciated!