My latest Ebay purchase was an EAGLE pancake padlock marked, "FAVORITE". My apology to the other bidder who tried to flank me with $26.00 in the last 3 seconds of the listing. You weren't even close to my maximum bid

.

This padlock was obtain in the locked position and without a key. I was very impressed with the overall condition of this lock. The body has virtually no dents or scrapes, and it would almost appear that the lock saw very little use. I immediately felt spring back on the hasp, which is the first indicator that the lock was not broken. Even the key hole was in great shape and well defined. Also, I was quick to noticed the well defined embossing, no wear around the letters.
The lever tumblers tell a different story. Strangely, some of the levers in the stack appear much thinner in the middle, almost knife-like, whereas some of the outer ones are much thicker and have more of a flush surface. There would be only two reasons for this varying degree of tumbler thicknesses. One, EAGLE used different thickness of tumblers in the stack. Second, some of the levers wore down giving the illusion of a thinner lever(s). Truly, it is quite common for interior levers to become worn that reside higher in the stack as seen when the lock is open.
I noticed that there was a large gap underneath the lever stack; enough room for a seventh tumbler. This implied that this lock was going to be rather easy to pick or decode, because the tolerance in the stack were not that great.
I tried tension on the hasp by using rope in order to pick the lock open. Only one lever out of six had set. I immediately knew that the lock was not going to open under this technique. I then decided to decode the lock open with the aid of my needle tools. The process began by using an L-wire to measure the gates of each lever tumbler (a process well discussed in this thread). I was able to open the lock using the first set of decoding data. The process took only 20 minutes. This was the easiest lock that I have ever decoded of this type in the shortest amount of time. Sometimes it takes hours. Obviously, the poor tolerances between lever tumblers was a huge advantage.
This is the first EAGLE pancake lock in my collection. Comparing this lock to a MILLER "CHAMPION" model, the EAGLE is .035 inch smaller in body diameter, .030 inch thinner in hasp thickness, .050 inch thinner in body thickness, and has a .355 inch wide keyhole compared to a .340 inch width. Anyone interested in obtaining one of these EAGLE locks for their collection should not be in too big of a hurry. Overall, I not impressed with the tolerances of the lever stack. The lock opens nicely with my decoding tool, but the stack will not reset unless the hasp is pushed down really hard, even after applying some silicone lubercant. A soft close will not lock the lock. This may explain why the lock is in such great condition. The original owner may have perceived the lock as defective and just stored it away. Anyway, I would have to say that this padlock is a cheaper quality in terms of mechanics than the MILLER models. Usually, EAGLE made better locks than the originals. So, this lock is somewhat of a disappointment. Sometime in the near future, I will make a working key.

