I hate to admit it, but this is the beginners’ forum after all. I’m relatively new to lock picking. I’ve been taking a slow and methodical approach to learning to pick following bosnianbills advice about starting with a Master #3 and progressing to 5-pin lock without security pins like the Master #17. I’d really like this to be more than a party trick, so I’ve been sticking with the picking of this lock for about three weeks. I practice most nights for a hour or so.
In preface, I’ve done the progressively pinned lock bit. I’ve started with one pin and progressed up to five. I thought I had a pretty good handle on what a binding pin felt like and what a non-binding pin felt like.
In truth I’ve become very discouraged and am about ready to give up. I thought at some point it might be the lock, the bitting might be too hard for me, so I got another Master #17. I can’t SPP that one either nor can I rake it. I have found that the first pin binds first. I can set that consistently. Other than that I am having trouble getting any feel from the lock. The pins don’t seem to bind. I’ve tried heavy tension and that just causes everything to jam. Medium tension still does not seem to get me any binding pins. I also can’t tell when or if I’ve set some of the other pins. Things won’t necessarily feel different or the feeling will be very, very subtle. Ambiguous at best. Pins two and three may set next but I’m not sure. I don’t know I’ve set anything until I release the tension and hear three or sometimes even four pins fall. What am I missing?
I've watched several YT videos to see other people pick it.
I’m not looking for or expecting anyone to tell me how to pick this lock. I guess I’m just looking for some encouraging words as I really don’t want to quit this hobby. How long should I practice on a lock before I set it aside? Is working an hour a day for several weeks without success normal? Am I some kind of newbie freak? If I do set it aside what type/kind of lock do I work on next? I have a Wilson Bohannan waiting but I’m fairly sure I can’t pick that if I can’t pick a Master #17. I'm nothing but frustrated at this point. What am I learning if I just keep doing the same thing over and over again?
I know I’m setting myself up for bit of ridicule for posting that I can’t pick a simple 5-pin lock. Everyone on here seems to run where I can hardly crawl.
I’m using a Peterson gem (0.025). I’ve tried top of key way tension and that just seems to complicate things more.
TL;DR:
Can't pick a Master #17
Help a newbie out?